KitchenScraps: Mum’s Legendary Scones by Mairi Neil

by Matilda Butler on February 18, 2010

catnav-scrapmoir-active-3Post #27 – Women’s Memoirs, ScrapMoir – Matilda Butler and Kendra Bonnett

By Mairi Neil, Victoria, Australia

My daughters, Anne and Mary Jane, after baking scones with Nana, 1994

My daughters, Anne and Mary Jane, after baking scones with Nana, 1994

Mum’s preparation and production of scones is a family legend. Her namesake, my daughter Anne, even proposed videotaping her baking for posterity. Regretfully, Mum passed away on 23rd October 2009 at the age of 88 before the video could be made.

When I baked a batch of scones for the first time since Mum’s death, Anne came home from work and plopped onto a kitchen chair to ask, “What are you cooking?”

Mairi-Neil-2-Scones“I’m trying to bake Nana’s scones,” I said, beating an egg furiously while holding back tears from moist eyes.

“No one can make scones like Nana — not even a good cook like you Mum.”

I managed a smile at the backhanded compliment. Anne’s honesty dispelled the awkward rush of sadness threatening to overwhelm me and I recalled a conversation I had with Mum the last time she stayed with us.

………

“You know Mum, Anne thinks your scone-making deserves to be filmed.”

Mum laughed, shaking her snowy white head in disbelief. “I couldn’t cook a boiled egg when I married your father in 1948. Had never been taught to cook or allowed in the kitchen by old Maggie, my stepmother.”

It was my turn to show surprise. Mum seemed such an expert and not just at cooking plain meals. Yet, I had never seen her consult a recipe. Her forte included scones, the specialty clootie (cloth) dumpling at Hogmanay, pancakes, soda bread, tattie (potato) scones and my favourite, treacle (molasses) scones. Many of the treats cooked on the traditional griddle atop the stove as well as in the oven. She combined her Irish heritage with recipes loved by my Scottish father and constantly adapted. In her first attempt cooking pasta, she produced a delicious lasagne but couldn’t remember the name, calling it “Los Angeles.” That’s what we still call it today.

Mum was also a dab hand at small cupcakes, which she iced with homemade blackberry jam sprinkled with coconut. With six children under ten, that innovation saved her precious hours of icing time and meant we could devour them straight away.

Curious about her cooking skill, I asked, “How did you become so good at baking, Mum?”

“Your dad taught me a lot. His mother had a heart condition most of his childhood and he had to help her.”

“I never saw Dad bake scones or cakes.”

“Oh, he didn’t teach me how to do everything but he gave me the confidence to experiment. He even ate my failures! A cook needs to be appreciated.”

I remember the Sunday mornings of my childhood. All of us in the double bed beside Mum and Dad, singing raucously:

There were eight in the bed and the little one said, roll over, roll over. So they all rolled over and one fell out…

Mum was always the first one out of bed to hurry downstairs to cook breakfast. She left the rest of us jockeying around dad. The baby had the privilege of yelling ‘roll over’ and much to our envy was always the last out of the bed, swung high on Dad’s shoulders and taken downstairs for breakfast.

There would be a large pot of porridge made from oats soaked overnight, and a loaf of toast buttered by the time we assembled in the dinette with olfactory glands and taste buds working overtime. Mum would be adding the finishing touch to Dad’s plate of bacon and eggs — either leftover boiled potatoes sliced and fried, or freshly made tattie scones from leftover mashed potatoes.

Did we show enough appreciation? I doubt it. I remember that Mum catered to all our whims: some wanted boiled eggs mashed in cups and others insisted on fried eggs flipped (or not), some asked for bread with crusts cut off while others thought the crusts were just fine, some thought soup should be strained of vegetables yet others wanted the vegetables in the bowl, some relished crispy bacon yet others thought the ham should be barely fried, some requested toast dry but others loved the butter, some drank tea so weak that it could have been warmed milk while others drank it so strong you could stand on it. Perhaps the oddest request of all that showed Mum’s love was to eat marmalade with the peel picked out.

Mairi Neil and Mum

Mairi Neil and Mum

On her last visit, I placed a breakfast tray in Mum’s lap and she murmured, “I’m sorry for putting you to all this bother.”

“Don’t apologize. How many times did you put yourself out for us?”

“That was nothing, part of my job as a mother.”

“And this is nothing, part of my job as a daughter.”

Grinning she continued to explain her cooking prowess. “I learned from recipes in the Women’s Weekly and The People’s Friend and I remembered watching Aunt Martha on the farm.” Mum’s milky eyes stared into the distance. Bony fingers that had been fussing with buttons on her cardigan suddenly stilled. Legally blind and struggling to see in the present, she was back on the farm of her childhood…

My maternal grandmother died in 1927, leaving Mum motherless at six years old. My grief-stricken grandfather, with a pawnbroking business to manage, plus two young children, accepted the offer of Grandmother’s family to take Mum and her three-year-old brother Tom, to their farm at Carricknaveigh, eighteen miles from Belfast. The same day she lost her mother, Mum effectively separated from her father apart from a visit on Sundays.

Six-year-old hands now fed hens and collected eggs in a wicker basket, patted the smooth flesh of horses released from yoke and plough, filled a trough with warm meal for the pigs and learnt to form letters in a tiny country school. She thrived on freshly picked vegetables, milk straight from the cow and meat from animals bred and killed on the farm.

“Those five years on the farm until my dad remarried and took Tom and I back to Belfast were the best years of my childhood,” she said.

From the first week of her arrival at the farm, Mum helped care for her dead mother’s older sister, Annie, who was her godmother. Annie suffered from a debilitating muscular disease that sounds similar to motor neurone disease or multiple sclerosis. She lay in bed 26 years, unable to do anything unaided while her muscles gradually seized. The last time she used words was the day she heard of her younger sister Mary’s death. Looking at Mum she murmured through twisted lips, ‘Poor bairns.’ After that she communicated with eye signals – one blink for yes, two blinks for no.

Annie’s hands were massaged with oil and Mum placed cotton wool between her fingers and in her claw hands to prevent sores and calluses. A woman from the village came daily to attend to Annie’s toilet needs and feed her, clean her room, help with general housework and supervise the children. She would read the Bible and any newspaper or pamphlet that came into the house to the poor woman lying trapped in her twisted body upstairs in the farmhouse. The children had to listen too although Mum confessed to sneaking away to hide in the barn to read comics or whatever novel she could find.

She remembered a day when Annie made the most horrible gurgling sounds trying to speak. Eyes blinking furiously, she stared in terror at the open window. Her pale skin blanched with sheen of perspiration. Had an intruder entered the room? Or perhaps ‘the shadow of death’ talked about in church? Mum’s blue eyes examined the open window, turned again to the moaning patient. She let out a blood-curdling scream that had adults running up the stairs two at a time.

Hovering above bedridden Annie was a giant wasp attracted by a vase of freshly picked Bluebells. The thought of its venomous sting had both Annies in a lather of fear.

Hands as soft as rose petals nurtured an ailing aunt from a very young age, and later nursed a father, who died in 1939, a few weeks after war was declared. “I returned to Belfast at eleven years of age, when dad remarried,” said Mum, unconsciously fingering her own wedding ring, “but life with Maggie was never happy. Dad died in my arms while I recited his favourite Bible passage, Psalm 23.”

Mum holding her large print Bible

Mum holding her large print Bible

I squeezed her arm, took both her hands in mine and thought of the many times these hands have been clasped in prayer and how her faith sustained her through life’s hurdles, gave her the courage to migrate to Australia at 40 years of age with a young family and start a new life – but that’s another story.

Mum
I think of you baking scones
Your floral apron streaked with flour.
Ingredients never measured but
swirled together by experienced hands
used to work and gifting love.
The soft splat of dough against Formica,
the thump of rolling pin and
scrape of metal cutter and then the
leftover scraps patted to shape a tiny scone
“For you – this special one,” you said.
© 2009 by Mairi Neil

Mairi-Neil-Recipe

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Mairi Neil coordinates the Mordialloc Writers’ Group, in Victoria Australia. She teaches creative writing at the Mordialloc Neighbourhood House and is currently studying for her Masters in Writing – a steep learning curve returning to study in her 50s. A widow, she lives with her daughters Anne and Mary Jane who enjoying eating but are yet to show an interest in cooking!

© 2010 Mairi Neil






{ 3 trackbacks }

uberVU - social comments
February 18, 2010 at
News: Memoir Contest Winner Announced — Memoir Writing
March 5, 2010 at
Memoir Writing Contest Award Winner for February — Memoir Writing Blog
March 19, 2010 at

{ 51 comments… read them below or add one }

Jake Coolman February 18, 2010 at

I have written down the recipe and will most definitely try it out…I do like scones though using cream is new to me…I have made similar using butter…and some using sour milk…this will be another addition to my cooking library…many thanks.

Judy Watters February 18, 2010 at

What a special memory you have to hold in your heart always, Mairi. so sweetly penned, your daughters will cherish this in years to come. I have precious memories of baking breads and sweet rolls with my father and pancakes and homemade applesauce with my mom. I wonder in this age of fastfood and prepared foods from the grocery store, if my granchildren will be able to enjoy these special times with their mom, my daughter. Thanks for allowing me to walk down your memory lane :)

Glenice February 18, 2010 at

I cried when I read this, Mairi. I remember your mother as a beautiful soul, so full of compassion and love. She is sadly missed, but her scone recipe will perpetuate her memory forever.

shirley randles February 18, 2010 at

Dear Mairi, what a wonderful story about your mother and her cooking. No wonder her scones were perfect. They were made with one extra ingredient: LOVE. She has left you and your family a wonderful legacy of so many happy memories. Shirley

Lynne February 18, 2010 at

Beautiful touching story about love for mother and family and it brought back many memories of my mother and grandmother. Thank you Mairi for sharing this part of your life, I know you are very close to your famil and I feel honoured to know you.

Louise February 18, 2010 at

It’s so hard to believe that your mum’s life began only two generations ago and she live almost a subsistence existence. Writers like you Mairi are our historians. Keep it up.

Lisa Hill February 19, 2010 at

This story reminds me of my mother’s tale about learning to make pastry from my grandmother. ‘Any fool can make pastry’ said Granny, but it’s not true (as those of us who have sampled stodgy pastry can testify). Granny didn’t use a recipe either, so my mother had to learn just by watching her, as I in my time learned from watching my mother.
Women passing on their skills, mother to daughter, a wondrous phenomenon, worldwide…

Patricia Rattray February 19, 2010 at

A wonderful love story Mairi. Your Mother must have loved you as much as you love her.
Thank you for sharing her.
I have copied the scone recipe and will have a go at it too.

Mairi Neil February 19, 2010 at

Dar Jake
hope you have success with the scone recipe – Mum made scones with buttermilk too, perhaps this is what you call sour milk? Thank you for reading my story.
Mairi

Mairi Neil February 19, 2010 at

Dear Judy
I’ll look forward to reading your wanderings down memory lane! Thankfully my daughters have sweet memories of cooking with their dad as well as their nana. In fact a memory scrapbook they made to display at John’s funeral had ‘John’s sausage rolls’! However, I can’t see their children having the same memories with their mum (my daughters). Perhaps KitchenScraps will become SuperMart Scraps! Thank you for reading my story and taking time to make a comment.
Mairi

Mairi Neil February 19, 2010 at

Dear Glenice,
Your wonderful novel Pickle to Pie was triggered with recipes and postcards and its fruition an inspiration to me and so many other writers. Thank you for reading Mum’s story.

Mairi Neil February 19, 2010 at

Dear Shirley
Thank you for reading Mum’s story – and like so many other stories on this website you are right – the main ingredient is LOVE! Matilda and Kendra do a fabulous job of encouraging women to write and record important family memories.

George February 19, 2010 at

Mairi Neils story on Mum’s Legendary Scones brought back some wonderful memories. Well done.

Mairi Neil February 19, 2010 at

Dear Lynne
thank you for your lovely comment and I know you have wonderful stories to share of a loving family too.

Mairi Neil February 19, 2010 at

Dear Louise
thank you for reminding us all that our stories are important and a gift for future generations.

Mairi Neil February 19, 2010 at

Dear Lisa
it is fabulous that the Internet has made this ‘wondrous phenomenon’ easier to share between nationalities and countries. Thank you for reading Mum’s story and I hope people check out your blog…

Mairi Neil February 19, 2010 at

Dear Pat
thank you for your kind words and good luck with the scones!

Mairi Neil February 19, 2010 at

Dear George
thank you – our wee Irish mum was a legend too wasn’t she?

Lucy February 19, 2010 at

Mairi,
What a special story of your mother’s baking and the story of her past. I am not a baker, but feel I must give your mother’s scone recipe a try, and I will share your story with my two daughters. Having lost my own ’special’ loving mother four years ago, I appreciate her more each day. Memories are forever. Thank you for sharing yours.

heather yourn February 19, 2010 at

What a beautiful tribute to a lovely lady. I look forward to ‘That’s another story’. Will now write about my Grandmother and Mother. You have inspired me as you usually do

Matilda Butler February 19, 2010 at

Heather:

I agree with you. I also want to hear the “That’s another story.” Perhaps we can all persuade Mairi to write another vignette and share another of her Mum’s special recipes.

-Matilda

Matilda Butler February 19, 2010 at

Mairi:

While the story of your Mum is wonderful, as the other commenters have said, I’d also like to mention your Aunt Annie. Today we would not expect a young child to care for a chronically ill relative for such an extensive period of time. From the rest of the story, it seems that experience may have helped forge your mother into the strong and caring woman that she clearly became.

This is a powerful story, well told.

-Matilda

heather yourn February 19, 2010 at

P.S.
It could be that your daughters will have as many ‘delicious’ memories of your apple cake as members of your writing groups. I vote 1 for Mairi’a cooking skills.

Jillian February 19, 2010 at

Dear Mairi,
What beautiful memories you have, and a very special way of expressing them to us. This story of your Mum has reminded me of my Grand Mother, who also made wonderful scones. If I was there to help, she would always say, ‘Always put your apron on, dear, when you are cooking’. I used to wonder if it made you a better cook…. perhaps for some!!
It is truly wonderful to have these warm memories, and they will stay forever in your heart.
I’ll certainly try making your Mother’s scones, I have not been a good scone maker,…..maybe this time !!
Thank you Mairi, lovely story of an exceptional woman in an exceptional life.
Jillian Rhodes–(I can almost smell scones baking in the oven,now)

Jake Coolman February 20, 2010 at

Hello again,
Today I have tried to make the scones and found it easier than making them with butter. AND they were delicious…all agreed on that, even the little puppy who couldn’t get enough scraps (he use to get the last piece of everyting we eat…well, almost everyting).
The “sour milk” was just that in my home country (Sweden). That is, it was milk that had soured and I guess it is the same as your buttermilk…we also used it to drink in the summer – very refreshing.
Your story has also made me plan to write something similar…that is, I will try to write some “Family Favorites” to give to future generations. My wife is a wonderful cook and our kids love her cooking and always ask me to provide them with the recipes…and that is not easy as my little wifey go by taste and not by any meausures…I have to watch what she is doing and then write down the guidelines and tell the kids to do as she does…taste, taste, taste…:-)
All the best and take care
An old fool living in paradise

Jo B February 20, 2010 at

Och, Mairi. Your mother comes to vibrant life in this touching memoir. I hope this is just one of many spotlights you shine into the world of your family.
Jo B

Catriona Gibson February 20, 2010 at

Mum was what I believe you would call a “Keeper” nothing was too much trouble, and her Love and Faith showed us the way for ever. “If a job’s worth doing it’s worth doing well” I can see her humming in the warm kitchen when we came home and the delicious smell of her baking would make our mouths water, and all this with no electrical appliances, or refrigerator. Your stories help us keep her memory alive, thank you, love from your Big Sister.

Mairi Neil February 20, 2010 at

Dear Catriona
Thank you big sister! Your wonderful memory and sharing of stories helps me write – and you have just added another layer to think about. Today with modern appliances we take for granted how quickly food can be planned and prepared. I remember sitting by the fire hugging the huge bowl with butter and sugar waiting for the butter to melt a little so we could start beating it – the first step on that magical journey of the fairy cakes!

Mairi Neil February 20, 2010 at

Dear Jake
Glad the recipe worked – and I hope to read a memoir from you including one of those delicious recipes from your wife – taste taste taste is the way to go – ask my daughters!

Mairi Neil February 20, 2010 at

Dear Lucy
thank you for your comment. I am writing about mum so that others know how special she was and it helps me to keep those memories vibrant.

Mairi Neil February 20, 2010 at

Dear Jillian
Thank you for sharing that special memory of your Grandmother and I am sure there are more stories you can write about while a batch of scones are cooking!

Mairi Neil February 20, 2010 at

Dear Heather
Thank you. I hope you checked out the other wonderful stories on this site! I look forward to reading your stories – the inspiration works both ways!

Mairi Neil February 20, 2010 at

Dear Matilda
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to share Mum’s story. Yes, I believe helping to care for a bedridden aunt had a profound effect on Mum. She later cared for her own father then became a nurse. Then she cared for my Papa, both of my Dad’s sisters and finally my Dad in the early stages of his dementia. Her Faith was her strength, Love her motivation.

Mairi Neil February 20, 2010 at

Dear Jo
thank you for encouraging me!

Matilda Butler February 20, 2010 at

Mairi:

What’s the “magical journey of the fairy cakes?” I think you should do another KitchenScraps for us that includes this story and recipe. I can hardly wait.
-Matilda

Rita Cordeux February 21, 2010 at

Dear Mairi
You have captured our mum/wee nana perfectly love ,caring for all,faith,compassion for all and never wanting to be a bother. I still can taste mums scones when I remember them ‘yum’.I am so proud of you well done.
love from your weeist sister

Kristina Rowell February 22, 2010 at

Dear Mairi
I marvel at my mum the same way, as she too has “golden hands” for making cakes, a trait which I think has skipped my generation! From what I have observed though it seems to require patience, love of sweets and a gentle touch, and I lack 2 out of 3! What a wonderful thing though, to leave such sweet memories behind. Shame your daughter never made a video of her grandma making scones. Perhaps you could make one together?

Mairi Neil February 22, 2010 at

Dear Rita
Your praise means a lot – thank you. The scones were especially yummy hot with the butter dripping like golden veins down the chin!

Maureen Hanna February 22, 2010 at

Dear Mairi,
Reading about your mother was a wonderful way to start my day. Your story made me cry at the thought of love given and love received every day, love that is never lost and is now shared not only with your immediate family but with people from around the world. I’m all for long-lived love and short-lived scones. When will the next plateful be served?

Helen February 22, 2010 at

Thanks for the beautiful story, it was almost like reading my own memories of baking with my mum.

Mum was such a fantastic baker and self taught. She always said cold hands had to be good for something. The family saying of using “love, attention and a little bit of spit” (metaphorically speaking) is continued to this day whenever any of us make something for our loved ones.

Jake Coolman February 23, 2010 at

Dear Mairi,
I do hope that I will find the time to write down the “Family Favorites” but it would only be something to give to our children and perhaps future generations.
I have no plans of publishing it…not yet anyhow.
In one of the other comments I read about the advice of video taping a cooking session…also that got me thinking – that would be a good idea and would put our video camera to good use…:-)
Though I have the feeling that it would be a bit more difficult than writing…
All the best and take care
The old fool in paradise

Mairi Neil February 23, 2010 at

Dear Maureen

as one writer to another – thank you and I think you have many wonderful stories to share too!

Mairi Neil February 23, 2010 at

Dear Helen
thank you for your kind comments. I laughed when you said ‘a little bit of spit’ – reminded me of my Dad’s fussiness about eating out and worrying if people washed their hands before cooking! I know you said metaphorically but the imagination of writers goes off at triggers and tangents – well this writer’s imagination does!

Mairi Neil February 23, 2010 at

Dear Kristina
thank you for your lovely comments and yes I do believe the digital age opens up lots of probabilities. I like the idea of digital storytelling and mixing of genres etc. Not sure me baking would be a great Youtube hit but certainly incorporating a video clip in a memoir has possibilities. The one sense that is so important for baking though is that delicious smell once the oven door is open – can that be captured?

Mairi Neil February 23, 2010 at

Dear Jake
I think videotaping a family cooking sessions is a great idea – look how popular celebrity cooking shows are! I think for a memoir telling the story of the recipe as you cook is important and perhaps adding some music.I have a video of my husband plucking a pheasant when we visited his family in England and he explains the ‘why and what’ and it is an important archive for our daughters because there is no way they will ever pluck a pheasant or perhaps even eat one in Australia.

Jake Coolman February 24, 2010 at

Thanks for your kind comments on the blog I am trying to keep for Jake.
I agree with the popularity of cooking shows, and we have the opportunity to watch “Food lovers guide to Australia” now and then, and there are so many others…I remember one with two old ladies on a motorbike that we thoroughly enjoyed too…not only for the food but for the narrative as well…One of the ladies had gone into a vegetarian restaurant and asked for the “meat option”…:-)
Anyhow, as for the video of your husband dressing a pheasant…which is a good topic for young people to learn from…but I bet you are happy that the possibility to record also smells isn’t available yet…it may be nice when baking but not so nice when removing the entrails from a bird…I know, I have had to do it…:-)
All the best and take care
The old fool in paradise

Kendra Bonnett February 24, 2010 at

“Mairi:
What’s the “magical journey of the fairy cakes?” I think you should do another KitchenScraps for us that includes this story and recipe. I can hardly wait.
-Matilda”

I second the motion, Mairi.

Carmen Green February 26, 2010 at

Thanks Mairi for your very moving story about the 3 generations of women in your family and the importance of your mother with her gentleness, her love and her cooking. I loved the glimpses into your mother’s life – a much harder life than most women today but perhaps more contented. I also loved Mairi’s format – memoir, photos and the great poem. Her ending left me wanting the other story about her mother’s trip to Australia with her 6 children.

Matilda Butler February 26, 2010 at

Mairi: You have a big fan club and we all want more stories and recipes. So far there have been votes for a KitchenScrap featuring the fairy cakes and the story of your mother’s trip to Australia. I’m sure that one also have a recipe or two you could include.

Kendra and I hope you don’t keep all of us waiting too long for these next stories.

-Matilda

Jake Coolman February 27, 2010 at

A gentle warning regarding these scones!
Since I tried out the recipe for the first time, I have had to make these scones every day…and the “not so little” pup comes running to the kitchen as soon as he can smell the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked scones…and my little wifey has asked for them at breakfast time as well as at dinner time…the first litre of cream is finished and I have had to buy more – and cream is not cheap here on the island.
Therefore this warning, if you try out the recipe you are likely to have to produce scones fairly often in the future…but to bake them every day does not take up too much of my time…and I enjoy eating them too, meaning that nobody have to push me very hard to bake them…:-)
All the best and take care
An old fool living in paradise

Leave a Comment

Interviews Category Interviews Category Interviews Category Interviews Category Interviews Category Interviews Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category StoryMap Category StoryMap Category StoryMap Category Writing and Healing Category Writing and Healing Category Writing and Healing Category Scrapmoir Category Scrapmoir Category Scrapmoir Category Book Business Category Book Business Category Book Business Category Memoir Journal Writing Category Memoir Journal Writing Category Memoir Journal Writing Category News Category News Category News Category