Memoir Author Talks about Self-Publishing

by Matilda Butler on August 16, 2012

Book Business PaperclipPost #97 – Women’s Memoirs, Book Business – Kendra Bonnett and Matilda Butler

Memoir Author Shares Insights into Decision to Self-Publish

Women’s Memoirs is delighted to welcome Destiny Allison today. We asked her to tell us about her publishing decision. We especially liked that she did her research, weighed the pros and cons, and then made a choice that works for her. If you already have your completed memoir or if you anticipate publishing in the future, then we think you’ll find valuable advice here.

But before I turn this over to Destiny, let me tell you a little about her and her new memoir Shaping Destiny. Destiny Allison is an artist, a business woman and a writer. Her work is collected by public institutions and private individuals internationally. In addition to her numerous awards for excellence in art, she was also named Santa Fe Business Woman of the year for 2011. Although we’re a bit late, congratulations Destiny.

In addition to being a full time artist, she is also a managing partner in La Tienda at Eldorado — a commercial complex, community center, and arts center in Santa Fe, NM. She is represented in prominent galleries across the country and owns her own gallery, Destiny Allison Fine Art, located at La Tienda.

And while art is her profession, Allison tells us that writing was her first love. Her early poems were published while she was a child and she received numerous awards during adolescence. The story of how she became a visual artist is told in her new memoir, Shaping Destiny: A quest for meaning in art and life.

The eloquence of Allison’s language dates back to her childhood when art was constantly discussed and debated by her father, a writer, and her mother, a painter. Born and raised in Santa Fe, N.M., Allison moved to Boston after college where she worked as a freelance journalist while raising her three children. It was there that she discovered her voice through sculpture. Predominantly self-taught, Allison apprenticed at a bronze foundry in Massachusetts, and later taught sculpture at the Attleboro Museum of Art and the Fuller Museum of Art, both in Massachusetts. In 1997, Allison returned to Santa Fe where she currently resides.

“Destiny, can you share with our readers your take on publishing? And, of course, we look forward to welcoming you back next week to discuss the writing of your memoir.”

Destiny-Allison, memoir

Why I Chose to Self-Publish

by Destiny Allison

I am so glad you asked this question Matilda. It is a really important topic given the current climate in the book industry and I am grateful for the opportunity to talk about it.

Before I made any decision regarding publication of Shaping Destiny, I did a ton of research. For over 6 months, while the book was in final editing, I read absolutely everything I could about publishing. I looked at traditional publishers who might be a good fit for my book and read every blog post I could find about other author’s experiences.

Finally, when all was said and done, I realized that self-publishing was the right avenue for me. The fact is, traditional publishers will not publish a new author who doesn’t have a platform. They pay a $3,000 to $5,000 advance on royalties and do not pay for marketing. Then, if the book does manage to sell, the royalty rate is between 6% and 15%.

If I chose to try to publish through traditional channels, I would have had to go out of pocket to market the book myself anyway, I would potentially never be fully compensated for my work, and I would give up all rights to my book. That last one was the final straw. If the book were traditionally published and didn’t sell well in the first few months, it would die. I couldn’t let that happen.

Self-publishing via print on demand and digital (ebook) publishing made it affordable for me to get the book into the market. Royalty rates are considerably higher as an Indie author. In addition, by self publishing I can give the book the time it needs to find the right readers and will, eventually, sell enough copies to recoup my investment and start to get paid for my work.

Beyond the purely financial incentives, there were two other equally important factors in my decision. The first was the time consideration. Finding a publisher can take years. Then, assuming a publisher can be found, it takes a book about 2 years to hit the market once a contract has been signed. I simply didn’t want to wait that long.

The other factor was that Shaping Destiny doesn’t fit neatly into any one genre. Realistically, that meant that it might never be picked up by a traditional publisher and I eventually might have had to go the Indie route anyway.

Finally, weighing in changes in the industry as a whole and the respect self-published authors are starting to garner, the fact that many well known authors including Steven King and J.K Rowling are self-publishing now, and the ease of publication companies like CreateSpace are providing, my choice was obvious.

Ultimately, I realized that I could do an equal or better job publishing my book than any traditional publisher. Consequently, I spent time and money hiring editors and a graphic designer so the book would be as good as it could be. I learned a ton about marketing books on the web and put that knowledge to good use. I have a long way to go, and lots of hard work in front of me, but in the end I believe the book will be more successful and get into more readers hands than it would have if I had pursued the traditional publishing route.

It is possible that in the future I will decide to contract with a publisher for this book or another one, but in the meantime not only is my book selling and getting some really great reviews, I am connecting with other women and artists around the world and building a community that is simply wonderful. This community is proving to be as rewarding as the royalty checks that come each month and I suspect, in the long run, it will be more valuable.

{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }

Grace Peterson August 17, 2012 at

Congratulations Destiny on your book. I just got back from Amazon, where I read the first few pages. Your writing is stellar. I wish you much success in your endeavor. I’ve got a finished memoir manuscript and have been querying Indie publishers. It is indeed a slow process. I’ve been researching self-publishing and appreciate your perspective. Two reasons I hesitate are, first the monetary outlay for a content editor. I’ve spent 6 years on my memoir and much of the editing I’ve done myself but I know I need a professional set of eyes to go over it before publishing. Secondly I like the idea of a publisher’s backing. The writing process is such a solitary endeavor that I would like the support of a sponsor. I wonder if you’d mind addressing these points.

Also, just a heads up. On Amazon there is a formatting issue with your Introduction or Preface. I was only able to read the last paragraph. The first part was missing.

Thank you and best wishes. And thank you Kendra and Matilda!

Grace Peterson August 17, 2012 at

Never mind. :) I reloaded the Amazon page and now your Author’s Note is visible. Sorry if I made you panic. :)

Destiny Allison August 18, 2012 at

Hi Grace,

Thanks for your comment and the kind words about my writing! The expense of an editor can be daunting, but you will end up paying for it one way or another. If you go with a traditional publisher, you will not receive royalties until you have sold enough books to cover your advance. However, there are a ton of author services out there that provide editorial assistance and the rates vary substantially. For me, it was worth the investment to hire someone who understood the unusual format of my book and grasped the concept behind it. Every traditional publisher I queried loved the writing but wanted me to radically change the structure. They missed the point of what I was doing. What is ironic is that most people who have now read my book say that the format is one of their favorite things about it.

As to going solo, I built my art career by going the Indie route first so it was a little easier to make the decision to do the same with my book. In the months since I launched I have been surprised and delighted by the community I am developing around it. Even more than the sales and positive reviews, this community of women is one for which I have looked for a very long time. Had I not taken on the responsibility for marketing my book in a serious way, I would not have met them and I would be much more alone in my writing world than I am now.

I do not think the indie route is for everyone or every book. I only know it is working for me. I invite you to trust yourself. It takes courage to write a memoir, and more courage to publish it. You are already so much further along than many. Good luck and I wish you much success.

Grace Peterson August 18, 2012 at

Thank you Destiny your your thoughtful reply. I’m really glad you were able to publish your book in the format you felt was right and that you had a supportive editor. I can understand your hesitation when a publisher is insisting you do it his/her way. It seems that many if not most publishers aren’t willing to take a risk on anything slightly different than their status quo. Definitely something I need to think about.

I know that whatever publishing route I end up going, the bulk of the marketing/publicity will be on my shoulders and I’m really looking forward to the challenge. I’ve been amazed at how many delightful, supportive people are out there, especially on the Internet and even right here on this site. :)

Leave a Comment

Interviews Category Interviews Category Interviews Category Interviews Category Interviews Category Interviews Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category Writing Prompts Category StoryMap Category StoryMap Category StoryMap Category Writing and Healing Category Writing and Healing Category Writing and Healing Category Scrapmoir Category Scrapmoir Category Scrapmoir Category Book Business Category Book Business Category Book Business Category Memoir Journal Writing Category Memoir Journal Writing Category Memoir Journal Writing Category News Category News Category News Category